My Application Form Status

Check the status of your application form with Angel Broking.
Arq - The Hyper Intelligent Investment Engine By Angel Broking

Can Indian MFs now match the clout of the Foreign Investors…

Stock Market | Published on May 23rd 2017 | Comment(s) 0
  • Subscribe to our mailing list

Over the last couple of year, domestic mutual funds have emerged as potent players in the equity and the debt markets. Mutual funds which were getting negative inflows till April 2014 have been seeing a spurt in retail inflows into equity funds. With other asset classes like real estate, gold and debt hardly giving returns post inflation, equity seems to be the only clear option for most Indian investors. That brings us to the key question; do mutual funds really influence markets as much as FIIs do? For that, let us look at the monthly flows data of FIIs and Mutual funds as disclosed in the NSDL reporting.

The chart above captures the monthly flows of FIIs into Indian equity and debt over the last 12 months. If you intuitively compare the flow numbers of the FIIs with the Nifty movement during the same period, there appears to be a direct correlation between the two. Post the Union Budget in 2016, FIIs turned net buyers in equities on reformist expectations. That was the period when the Nifty rallied sharply. Post October, FIIs turned net sellers in equity and debt in the aftermath of the Fed rate hike expectations and worries over demonetization. It was during this period that markets were extremely tepid. However, post February 2017, when FIIs turned aggressive buyers in debt and equity, the Nifty rallied to a new high. This has been the typical situation over the last 15 years, wherein the FIIs have exerted an inordinately high influence on the market levels.

Let us now focus on the mutual fund action and its impact on the Nifty. In the first half of 2016, domestic mutual funds were largely tepid buyers but FIIs were aggressive buyers which resulted in a runaway rally post the Union budget 2016. In the post demonetization period, MFs continued to be aggressive buyers in equity and debt. But the Nifty remained tepid to weak. However, it must be conceded that had it not been for the support of the domestic mutual funds, Indian markets could have cracked really sharply under the onslaught of FII selling during that period. To that extent domestic MFs have played a role in shielding the market; even if not in influencing it.

Why do FII flows exert more influence on the Nifty movement?

There are 5 key reasons for this phenomenon, which explains why the FIIs exert a greater influence on the Indian market movement…

  1. As a share of ownership, FIIs own nearly 25% of the overall equity of India’s top 100 stocks. This is only lower than promoters who hold an average of 49% in Indian companies. Mutual funds, on the other hand, hold less than 10% in the equity of Indian companies. This obviously makes them a less influential player when it comes to impacting the Nifty levels.
  2. FII investments are restricted to the index stocks and the leading stocks that are present in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index. This is contrary to the domestic mutual funds which focus more on mid-cap and small cap funds in search of alpha. The need for alpha is much less in case of FIIs and large cap stocks are good enough to provide that.
  3. FIIs tend to behave in droves more often than the mutual funds do. Most FIIs are actually executing orders on behalf of large macro players like hedge funds, index funds, ETFs and sovereign funds. They typically take macro calls on the markets and that leads to bunching of selling or buying from FIIs. Hence their influence on the Nifty tends to get magnified.
  4. FIIs have end-investors who are essentially institutions and hence they happen to be stickier. On the other hand, the clientele for equity mutual funds are predominantly retail investors. They have a limit to the MTM losses that they can afford to take. The situation of retail flows into equity MFs has been consistently positive over the last 3 years. However, that may be deceptive. Prior to that, equity mutual funds had seen consistent retail outflows for 61 months in succession. The source of influence of the mutual funds can shift quite fast.
  5. Lastly, there is a very important currency angle to the whole story. For example, when Mutual Funds infuse money in the market, it is purely an impact on equities. On the other hand when FIIs bring in money, the impact is felt on the equity markets as well as the INR due to dollar inflows. This dual impact makes the FII flows more influential compared to domestic mutual fund flows.

The crux of the story is that, as of now, FIIs continue to exert more influence on the Indian equity markets. But the experience of the second half of 2016 indicates that sharp inflows from mutual funds have been instrumental in providing a support to markets. That by itself may be a good starting point for mutual funds to exert greater influence on Indian equity markets.

Add new comment